The Times, November, 2005
What’s the correct emotional response to news that a Category 4 storm is heading toward a city of unique and global cultural consequence? It’s impossible to conceive of a jazz or American music enthusiast anywhere who didn’t experience a kernel of panic as the story of breached levees and catastrophic floods began to emerge. Until August 29 2005, Buddy Bolden’s 1902 clarion call cornet tone - the very first note in a century of jazz and a sound so diamond clear it was said to carry out of New Orleans and across the Louisiana state line - could still just about be heard. Its continued echo wasn’t just down to the way it remains lodged in jazz’s musical DNA, shaping the breaths of jazz trumpeters from Beijing to Brussels. It was absolutely at its most concentrated and valuable in New Orleans, where it continued to simmer in a racial, cultural, architectural stew that hadn’t left the heat in hundreds of years. New Orleans was America’s Vienna.
And then as witness-reports and pictures filtered out - of bloated bodies floating past houses; people, who had had little before, left with nothing; packed hospitals without power or water - it seemed almost obscene, a guilty spoilt indulgence, to be worrying about the romance of streets once trodden by a young Louis Armstrong.
According to Bob Hurwitz, president of Nonesuch Records, there is no correct emotional response to Katrina.